Thursday, April 27, 2017

Virtue, Nationhood, and Islam

There may not be a commonly understood definition of virtue, at least when it comes to choosing between your nation and your religion.  I've begun to wonder if that is one of the principal reasons for the rise of Islamic terrorism.

Some virtuous people may shrink from killing for their nation.  These are the pacifists who choose jail over conscription.  But in the modern world, and in most societies, one's national identity is understood as being more primary and basic than one's religious identity.  And so most people who believe killing can sometimes be justified and necessary will kill for their nation.  Most people consider killing for their religion unvirtuous under any circumstances.

What about Muslims?  Does the typical Muslim consider it justifiable to kill for their religion under certain circumstances?  Does he/she hold allegiance to "the Umma" a higher goal than allegiance to nationhood?

I've begun to wonder if that is the elephant in the room that is not discussed.